Microlending: The best startup idea I’ve heard in five years.

Microlending, peer-to-peer lending, or social lending is something I’ve been keeping my eye on for the last year. It’s an auction service that bypasses banks and lets individuals loan money directly to the borrowers. It is quickly becoming a legitimate investment option and it won’t be long before it bursts into the mainstream finance world.

The concept is that people who need money request it, and other people bid for the privilege of lending it to them. These lenders spread their loans across numerous borrowers, reducing their exposure to defaults. The borrowers’ loans are filled by “syndicates” of lenders who have bid different dollar amounts on different interest rates.

Several companies have products in this space, including CircleLending and UK-based Zopa. But by far, the biggest US startup is Prosper.com. Here’s their example that explains how the service works:

1. Joe Davis, Volunteer Firefighter, needs a small loan. So he posts a listing for a loan with the amount he needs and a rate he can afford.
2. Lisa Barron has a little bit of money to lend. Lisa, along with other lenders like her, bid on Joe’s listing with an amount they’re willing to lend at a rate they think is fair.
3. When the listing ends, the bids with the lowest rates are combined into a single 3-year loan for Joe. Each month, Joe’s payment is deducted from his bank account and deposited into his lenders’ accounts until the loan is repaid.

I haven’t been this excited about a company since Google and eBay were doing their IPOs. Its a hugely disruptive concept that takes banks out of the loan business. Over the next ten years, it will completely change the credit industry. Like eBay, the bigger the network of borrowers and lenders, the better the service will be.

I’m going to open up an account with Prosper.com, the biggest of the US startups. One of my worries is the level of risk I’m accepting that my borrowers will default on their loans. Forbes eased those concerns in an article called “The eBay of Loans” by providing some quantifiable data on the risk:

What if things don’t work out for borrowers? In its year of existence Prosper has had 0.5% of total loan amounts default and 6.5% fall behind on payments for a month, compared to 4.2% and 4.4% for card companies. Prosper lenders choose among three collection agencies to pursue delinquent borrowers.

Interesting. The 0.5% default rate seems incredibly low. However, Forbes points out some inevitable problems with the system:

While bad loans are minor now, just wait until an economic downturn comes along. Another problem for Prosper lenders is that the loans are not liquid. The company had hoped to set up a secondary market, but that fell through. Lenders are stuck for a loan’s whole three-year term.

I’m surprised there’s not a secondary market for the loans. It seems like that would be trivial compared to setting up the loan system in the first place. Forbes also backs me up in thinking that microlending is on it’s way to the professional finance arena:

While most Prosper lenders are amateurs, some investment pros are dipping in. Jonathan Hoenig, 31, runs Capitalistpig Hedge Fund in Chicago and has more than $150,000 of its money in 1,300 Prosper loans at an average interest rate of 20%. “This is a way to run a credit card company,” he says.

I go now to open up my Prosper account and start playing. I’ll let you know how it goes.

Reddit Digg Technorati

5 Comments »

  1. Andrew said,

    May 9, 2007 at 9:56 pm

    Hi Matt - Andrew from Prosper here. Thanks for your post. The comment in the Forbes article about how the secondary market “fell through” was a misstatement. We are, in fact, planning on providing a secondary market, but it requires regulatory clearance at a level above and beyond what is needed to make loans in the first place. In any event, it is in the works.

  2. Matt Abar said,

    May 11, 2007 at 7:18 pm

    Interesting. I was thinking that re-selling the loans would be similar to eBay. But actually it would be more like e*Trade and require a securities license. Good to know it’s in the works.

  3. WealthFly » Interesting Web 2.0 Article said,

    May 18, 2007 at 10:39 pm

    […] Another great Web 2.0 example is Prosper.com, which I blogged about last week. Sidebar: I’ve been trying unsuccessfully to set up an account. I’m hoping the nice Prosper.com employee who posted earlier (and obviously tracks all mentions of the site) could intervene for me. I answered one of the verification questions incorrectly and have been waiting a week for a phone call to re-verify my information. Thx. […]

  4. WealthFly » Loaning Money with Prosper.com said,

    July 17, 2007 at 6:08 pm

    […] For anybody who hasn’t read my last post, Prosper.com is a way to borrow or lend money that completely bypasses banks. It uses a auctions to establish borrowing rates based on borrower’s credit scores and other personal information they care to provide. Lenders can spread their capital across numerous borrowers, minimizing the impact of a single default. […]

  5. WealthFly » MicroPlace - All The Risk Of Emerging Markets Investing Without The Reward said,

    December 12, 2007 at 7:31 pm

    […] is similar to Prosper (which Matt wrote about here and here); Prosper is a general lending program available to everyone in the United States.  These […]

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URL

Leave a Comment